Whilst doing the change of stator, I also changed the bearing block. I had to deliver on a promise to Michael Lawley that once winter flows arrived, I would run another trial of ceramic bearings. The first trial was done in June and the bearings lasted just 4 weeks.
This second trial started yesterday, - and finished yesterday ! Just 8 hours ! Inspection of the failed bearings showed much the same as the first trial: pitted balls causing locking up of the race, but this time there was also abrasion of the PTFE spacer ring, leaving particles of PTFE everywhere. I think this has to be the end of the road for the ceramic bearing dream !
In the course of this repeated delving into the turbine, I have progressed the idea of trying to run the Smart Drive compartment as dry as possible. This I've done by stopping the ingress of moist outside air by blocking off the ventilation ports and de-humidifying the captive air inside with bags of silica gel.
It seems easily possible to obtain very low levels of relative humidity. Ten bags of silica gel, each of 100g, brings the humidity down to just 10% within an hour of closing the housing, and this is with an outside ambient humidity of 98%.
The rise in temperature is to about 6 ℃ above ambient when the power output to grid is 300 W. At the reading showing this morning, 22.4 ℃, I am happy with this, although as power output increases in coming weeks, and with it greater heat output from the alternator, the rise in temperature will have to be watched.
To touch briefly on the theory of humidity and its relationship to dew point, if the relative humidity inside the housing can be kept at this 10% level and the temperature in the housing does not rise above 36 ℃, it will completely prevent any condensation (which is dew) forming on the bulkhead, even when the temperature of the bulkhead gets down to 0 ℃. Since it is condensation forming on the bulkhead and then dribbling down over electrical components which probably causes most of the issues with insulation breakdown, this would be a significant advance.
The unknown will be how often the silica gel bags will need 're-charging', and the answer to that will be how often the compartment is opened allowing an air change with moist outside air. I'll be keeping my inspections there to a minimum.
For those interested, 25 silica gel bags of 100 g cost £18.59 and a useful dew point calculator can be found here.
2 comments:
Hola Bill, que tal todo?
Feliz año lo primero y gracias por todo tu aporte a la comunidad!
1 duda, tengo que cambiar a mi powerspout lh150 con 2m de altura y 375w de potencia útil los rodamientos, es factible los rodamientos cerámicos de Zirconio? has hecho nuevas pruebas? aunque aguanten menos si gira mas suave y gano un 10-12w al igual me lo planteo, lo siguientes será meterle un BLDC a medida mas pequeño para no andar subiendo el 50% del rotor, pero me urge mas el cambio de los rodamientos!! muchas gracias de antemano y sigue mostrándonos avances!! saludos
Hello Tenas DJ
Thank you for your comment.
For those not fluent in Spanish, I'll post a translation of your question below.
To answer your question, from my experience with trialling ceramic bearings, I would NOT advise you to use them. The ones I trialled were more expensive than even the most expensive SKF steel ball bearings, and they did not last even a few weeks.
I am not familiar with the bearings on the LH 150 and have never done a service on such a turbine.
My own firm preference for choice of bearing in my turbine, which being a pelton will have a much faster rpm than your LH, is to use the SKF Energy Efficient series of deep groove ball bearings.
They have a 'rolling resistance' which is almost as good as ceramics, and they last for years.
I hope this helps; good luck with the other modifications you mention.
Bill
Hi Bill, how's it going?
Happy New Year first of all, and thanks for all your contributions to the community!
I have one question: I need to replace the bearings on my PowerSpout LH150, which is 2 meters tall and has a usable power output of 375W. Are zirconium ceramic bearings a viable option? Have you done any new tests? Even though they might not last as long, if it makes the fan spin smoother and I gain 10-12W, I'm considering it. Next, I'll install a smaller, custom-made BLDC fan so I don't have to increase the rotor size by 50%, but I'm more urgent about changing the bearings! Thanks in advance, and please keep us updated on your progress! Cheers!
Post a Comment